Get our issue, highlights, free stuff and more!  

  • About MT
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • STORE
  • RSS Feeds

Detroit Metro Times home page.

  • NEWS
  • ARTS
  • CULTURE
  • MUSIC
  • SCREENS
  • FOOD+DRINK
  • CALENDAR
  • BLOGS
  • BEST OF
  • FREE STUFF
  • CLASSIFIEDS
  • MMJ
  • ARCHIVES
  • BLOWOUT
  • REFER LOCAL
News+Views Cover Stories News Hits Politics & Prejudices Stir It Up Higher Ground
Music Blahg News Blawg The B-Roll Reckless Eyeballing The Subterraneans
Arts Lit Up
Music Album Reviews Browse Local Music Music Events Add Your Act
Stories+Reviews Film Reviews Idiot Boxing Cheat Code
Food Stories Restaurant Reviews Find a Restaurant Find a Club Happy Hours Add a Restaurant Add a Club
Search Events Add an Event
Best of Detroit 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2004 2003 Best of Map
EVENT PHOTOS MT ON FACEBOOK MT ON TWITTER MT ON FLICKR
Classifieds Home Place an Ad Dating Real Estate Jobby Jobster
Culture Savage Love Motor City Cribs & Rides
Search Articles Search Authors Search Issues Latest Comments
BLOWOUT HOME HISTORY PRESS PHOTOS BLOWOUT BLOG
MEDICAL MARIJUANA HOME

Calendar

Restaurants

Clubs

  • Latest Comments
  • Popular Threads
  • Most Read
Most Read
  • The Whole truth That $5 million spent luring Whole Foods drives city’s independent grocers crazy | 5/16/2012
  • The devil inside The people who attend this church swear they see miracles. Who's to argue? | 5/2/2012
  • Your College Bucket List The must-do highlights of higher learning | 8/24/2011
  • Malcolm X — still controversial A recent biography stirs debate as the iconic black nationalist is honored in Detroit | 5/16/2012
  • Marijuana mea culpa Last week, we got some stuff wrong — but here’s the straight dope | 5/16/2012
  • Motown revival Remembering the Marvelettes and the hit factory's beginnings | 5/16/2012
  • Nutritional Value - Readers' Choice Our readers pick the best places to scarf, nosh, tipple and dine | 4/27/2011

Print Email

Screens

The First Grader

The First Grader aggressively uplifts above any flaws

Photo: , License: N/A

Lovely Naomie Harris inspires in the The First Grader.


By Corey Hall

Published: June 1, 2011

The First Grader

GRADE: B

In 2004, when the Kenyan government at long last declared the right to free elementary schooling for all citizens, one of the first students to grab a pencil was Kimani N'Gan'ga Maruge. The only difference between him and his wide-eyed grade school classmates is roughly eight decades of life experience. The elderly man simply wants to read; to receive the education could never afford, and maybe regain some stolen dignity in the process. Maruge is veteran of the Mau Mau rebellion in the '50s, where factions of Kikuyu tribe battled the British colonialists and their supporters; including many of their own families and countrymen. Some of those buried tribal enmities run very deep, and the legacy of the rebellion remains untidy and painful to many still bearing grudges. Prison camp survivor Maruge's presence in the over-crowded rural classroom sends community leaders into an uproar, but he's firmly defended by teacher Jane Obinchu (Naomie Harris) who doesn't view him as a saint, but respects the huge personal debt he paid in the nation's struggle for independence.

Based on real events, this heart warming, well-intentioned film is engaging and evocative, despite some clumsy and ham-fisted direction by journeyman Justin Chadwick (The Other Boleyn Girl).

The storytelling is direct and straightforward, but often too on the nose. There are too many explicit flashbacks to the tragedies Maruge suffered during the war. The suggestion of atrocity is usually enough to get the point across, but Chadwick keeps hammering us with gory details and overwrought scenes of tragedy. He's equally heavy handed with the domestic squabbles of Jane and her husband, who is of course opposed to his wife's lonely crusade. When not bathing in melodrama, the tone is so aggressively uplifting that you'll half expect Paul Simon to hop out of the bushes and start playing side one of Graceland.

The First Grader is mawkish and manipulative; but so what?

The starkly beautiful African backdrops, and strong, heartfelt performances by both adults and children overwhelm the script's hokier instincts, and give us a noble cause worth rooting for. With a man this brave, and a goal so basically good and thoroughly wholesome, cynicism seems like an affront.

Showing at the Maple Art Theatre 4135 W. Maple Rd., Bloomfield Hills; 248-263-2111.

> Email Corey Hall

We welcome user discussion on our site, under the following guidelines:

To comment you must first create a profile and sign-in with a verified DISQUS account or social network ID. Sign up here.

Comments in violation of the rules will be denied, and repeat violators will be banned. Please help police the community by flagging offensive comments for our moderators to review. By posting a comment, you agree to our full terms and conditions. Click here to read terms and conditions.
comments powered by Disqus


News

News+Views

Politics & Prejudices

News Hits

Stir It Up

Higher Ground

Comics

Blogs

Music Blahg

News Blawg

Reckless Eyeballing

The B-Roll

Blowout Blog

Best of Detroit

Best of Detroit

Best of Detroit 2010

Best of Map

Music

Music Homepage

Album Reviews

Add Music Event

Search Music Events

Arts

Arts Homepage

Book Reviews

Culture

Culture Homepage

Savage Love

Motor City Cribs & Rides

Screens

Screens Homepage

Film Reviews

Idiot Boxing

Events

Calendar

Search Calendar Events

Enter Calendar Event

Food

Food Homepage

Find a Restaurant

Clubs

Find a Club

Web

MT Newsletter

MT@Facebook

MT@MySpace

MT@Flickr

MT@Twitter

MT@Youtube

Archives

Search Archives

Search Authors

Search Issues

Latest Comments

Classified

Classified Home

Place Ad

Jobs

Services

Stuff For Sale

Massage

Personals

Adult

Automotive

Cars, Trucks+More

Services

Real Estate

Real Estate

For Rent

Roommates

Contact Us

About us

Staff Directory

Advertise

National Advertising

Work Here

Metro Times Stuff

Win Free Stuff

Velvet Rope Photos

Event Photos

RSS Feed

 Full Feed

© 2012 Metro Times