Get our issue, highlights, free stuff and more!  

  • About MT
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • STORE
  • RSS Feeds

Detroit Metro Times home page.

  • NEWS
  • ARTS
  • CULTURE
  • MUSIC
  • SCREENS
  • FOOD+DRINK
  • CALENDAR
  • BLOGS
  • BEST OF
  • FREE STUFF
  • CLASSIFIEDS
  • MMJ
  • ARCHIVES
  • BLOWOUT
  • REFER LOCAL
News+Views Cover Stories News Hits Politics & Prejudices Stir It Up Higher Ground
Music Blahg News Blawg The B-Roll Reckless Eyeballing The Subterraneans
Arts Lit Up
Music Album Reviews Browse Local Music Music Events Add Your Act
Stories+Reviews Film Reviews Idiot Boxing Cheat Code
Food Stories Restaurant Reviews Find a Restaurant Find a Club Happy Hours Add a Restaurant Add a Club
Search Events Add an Event
Best of Detroit 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2004 2003 Best of Map
EVENT PHOTOS MT ON FACEBOOK MT ON TWITTER MT ON FLICKR
Classifieds Home Place an Ad Dating Real Estate Jobby Jobster
Culture Savage Love Motor City Cribs & Rides
Search Articles Search Authors Search Issues Latest Comments
BLOWOUT HOME HISTORY PRESS PHOTOS BLOWOUT BLOG
MEDICAL MARIJUANA HOME

Calendar

Restaurants

Clubs

  • Latest Comments
  • Popular Threads
  • Most Read
Most Read
  • The Whole truth That $5 million spent luring Whole Foods drives city’s independent grocers crazy | 5/16/2012
  • The devil inside The people who attend this church swear they see miracles. Who's to argue? | 5/2/2012
  • Your College Bucket List The must-do highlights of higher learning | 8/24/2011
  • Malcolm X — still controversial A recent biography stirs debate as the iconic black nationalist is honored in Detroit | 5/16/2012
  • Fifty Shades of annoyance At 19 years of marriage, novel stirs up her libido, what about his? | 5/16/2012
  • Nutritional Value - Readers' Choice Our readers pick the best places to scarf, nosh, tipple and dine | 4/27/2011
  • Battleship Sinking ship — Plus, Rihanna plays a stoic weapons specialist! | 5/18/2012

Print Email

Screens

Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Part 1

Go. Don't go. Nothing I write will make a difference. Still here? Very well.

Photo: , License: N/A

Everyone wants a piece of ![CDATA[]].


By Jeff Meyers

Published: November 19, 2010

Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Part 1

GRADE: B+

It was with the last Harry Potter film — The Half Blood Prince — that director David Yates gave up trying to create a stand-alone installment and simply accepted that audiences were either with Harry or they weren't. Dark and menacing, it was the most understated and human film in the series, ushering in a rich emotional subtext and new maturity to the characters. It was also highly episodic and practically indecipherable to anyone new to J.K. Rowling's epic.

The Deathly Hallows, Part 1 continues that trend and then some, offering up a formless film with no beginning and no end, just an unrelenting road-movie middle.

Dumbledore is dead, Voldemort (Ralph Fiennes) and his Death Eaters are ascendant, and a full-scale war is brewing. With the Ministry of Magic transformed into a sorcery-wielding version of the Third Reich and wanted posters calling for Harry's (Daniel Radcliffe) head, the teen magician and his pals, Hermione (Emma Watson) and Ron (Rupert Grint), take off for the wilds, evading Voldemort's minions and searching for the four remaining Horcruxes — pieces of Voldemort's soul that will allow Harry to defeat his nemesis once and for all.

It's bleak and desperate stuff, telegraphed by the crumbling Warner Brother's logo that kicks things off. Long gone is the warmth and whimsy of Hogworts' banquets and Quidditch games. They've been replaced by an impending magic-fueled doomsday. Easily the most mature and complex film in the series, Deathly Hallows, Pt 1 (Part 2 will be released in June) skips the trademark breathless exposition of past chapters while brazenly tossing around Potterbabble. Alternating between harrowing drama and lumbering plot turns, we follow the trio of friends into a magnificently wintery wilderness, luminously captured by cinematographer Eduardo Serra. Now on the brink of adulthood, they struggle with jealousy, loss and sexual unease as they attempt to unlock secrets from Dumbledore's past while securing the weapons they'll need to finally vanquish Voldemort.

And though some key action moments disappointingly occur off-screen (including the deaths of various minor characters), it's the first Harry Potter film that doesn't feel like it's crammed to the gills with name-checked plot points. Though the pace may be slower than necessary (especially in the film's middle section), Yates has injected some long-awaited breathing room, allowing the leads to emerge as three-dimensional characters.

While some may lament the too-brief appearances by Britain's top performers (particularly the always great Alan Rickman), Radcliffe, Watson and especially Gint prove that they've actually grown into very fine actors, capable of handling emotional nuance and contradiction. The film's middle section (to call it an act would be generous) focuses on the trio's friendship and offers up one of the most touching moments in the movie: Harry pulling Hermione into an awkward and impromptu dance.

1 2 Next Page

> Email Jeff Meyers

We welcome user discussion on our site, under the following guidelines:

To comment you must first create a profile and sign-in with a verified DISQUS account or social network ID. Sign up here.

Comments in violation of the rules will be denied, and repeat violators will be banned. Please help police the community by flagging offensive comments for our moderators to review. By posting a comment, you agree to our full terms and conditions. Click here to read terms and conditions.
comments powered by Disqus


News

News+Views

Politics & Prejudices

News Hits

Stir It Up

Higher Ground

Comics

Blogs

Music Blahg

News Blawg

Reckless Eyeballing

The B-Roll

Blowout Blog

Best of Detroit

Best of Detroit

Best of Detroit 2010

Best of Map

Music

Music Homepage

Album Reviews

Add Music Event

Search Music Events

Arts

Arts Homepage

Book Reviews

Culture

Culture Homepage

Savage Love

Motor City Cribs & Rides

Screens

Screens Homepage

Film Reviews

Idiot Boxing

Events

Calendar

Search Calendar Events

Enter Calendar Event

Food

Food Homepage

Find a Restaurant

Clubs

Find a Club

Web

MT Newsletter

MT@Facebook

MT@MySpace

MT@Flickr

MT@Twitter

MT@Youtube

Archives

Search Archives

Search Authors

Search Issues

Latest Comments

Classified

Classified Home

Place Ad

Jobs

Services

Stuff For Sale

Massage

Personals

Adult

Automotive

Cars, Trucks+More

Services

Real Estate

Real Estate

For Rent

Roommates

Contact Us

About us

Staff Directory

Advertise

National Advertising

Work Here

Metro Times Stuff

Win Free Stuff

Velvet Rope Photos

Event Photos

RSS Feed

 Full Feed

© 2012 Metro Times