• About MT
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • STORE
  • RSS Feeds

Get our issue, highlights, free stuff and more!

  • Blogs
  • News
  • Arts+Culture
  • Music
  • Screens
  • Food
  • Calendar
  • Best of Detroit
  • Classifieds
  • Slideshows
  • Free Stuff
  • Careers
  • Dating
  • Clubs
  • Archives
  • MMJ
  • Blowout
  • Adult Classifieds
  • Calendar

    • Latest Comments
    • Popular Threads
    • Most Read
    Most Read
    • Penrose Rising Changes are under way. | 5/15/2013
    • They Don’t Care What You Think They don’t care what you want | 5/15/2013
    • Film Review: Upstream Color A brain-controlling parasite gives a man the locust-like ability to suck the will — and cash — from his unwitting victim. | 4/24/2013
    • Short takes Dressing up as a woman, technical butt-plug question, steal some porn mags, drunk straight girls, spanking someone with consent is sexy, and more | 5/15/2013
    • Daughter of the revolution How Jesse Smith became a force in Detroit music | 2/22/2012
    • Film Review: Star Trek into Darkness Abrams’ second reboot goes where we’ve all been before, but boldly. | 5/17/2013
    • Why Brooks Patterson Was Right Coming Out and Courage | 5/8/2013

    Print Email

    Cover Story

    How the Capitol exploded

    Last week, Lansing's cold war got hot

    Photo: N/A, License: N/A

    Photo: , License: N/A

    Protests in Lansing last week did not deter the GOP from passing so-called right-to-work bills.


    View Image Gallery for How the Capitol exploded Image Gallery for How the Capitol exploded Image Gallery for How the Capitol exploded

    By Curt Guyette

    Published: December 12, 2012

    Editor's Note: This is an updated version of the story that appears in this week's print edition of the Metro Times.

     

    Michigan is on the verge of doing something that would have been absolutely unthinkable even a few years ago.

    Unless there is a dramatic turnaround, this state — a place that helped give birth to the modern labor movement, a cornerstone in the building of the American middle class — is very likely to become the 24th state to enact some form of so-called "right to work" law that will put already embattled unions in an even more precarious position.

    What happened?

    Some, on both the left and the right, say that the unions themselves are at least partly to blame. These observers point to what they describe as a monumental tactical error made by big labor when it poured millions of dollars into ballot measures that went before voters in November, effectively posing a direct challenge to the policies of Gov. Rick Snyder. 

    In doing so, labor both exposed some of its own weakness and aroused the ire of a governor who had professed to be moderate, spurring him to side with the reactionary forces in his Republican Party. 

    The characterization of recent events is a matter of some dispute.

    What can't be disputed, however, is that conservative forces in Michigan have been pursuing the goal of "right to work" for decades. 

    Until now, that goal has been unattainable. But in recent days we've witnessed a convergence of factors that amounted to a sort of perfect political storm. 

    Previously, Gov. Snyder was on record as saying that "right to work" wasn't part of his "agenda" because it is such a divisive issue. Instead of creating massive conflict over RTW, he said he preferred to pursue other policies to help Michigan's economy recover.

    Say what you want about the governor, but there's no denying that he was absolutely correct about RTW being divisive. More than 10,000 union members and their supporters showed up at the Capitol on Tuesday in a last-ditch effort to prevent final legislative approval of two RTW bills — one for the private sector and one for public employees (with an expected "carve out" for police officers and firefighters). The massive demonstration failed to stop the legislation from being rammed through. The two bills now only need the governor's signature to become law.

    Last week, state police attempted to keep protesters out of the Capitol as the RTW bills were being rushed through both houses. Two injunctions had to be issued in order to open the way for the public, who found that GOP staff members had occupied seats.

    It was an ugly and disgraceful scene unworthy of a democracy.

    Facing facts

    Let's get one thing straight: There is something absolutely Orwellian about calling the bills pushed through the Legislature "right to work" laws.

    "To begin, the term 'right to work' ... is a misnomer," writes Roland Zullo, a research scientist at the University of Michigan's Institute for Labor and Industrial Relations. 

    In a paper titled "What 'Right to Work' Would Mean for Michigan," Zullo goes on to explain: "RTW has nothing to do with the right of a person to seek and accept gainful employment."

    Instead, it has to do with the ability of labor unions to negotiate what are called "security agreements" with employers.

    Kenneth G. Dau-Schmidt, a professor of labor and employment law at Indiana University's Maurer School of Law, emailed the Metro Times a detailed opinion piece he previously wrote explaining exactly what it is these agreements entail and why they are important:

    "These agreements require that, as a condition of employment, all employees in the bargaining unit either join a union and pay full dues, or at a minimum pay the union a smaller 'agency fee' equal to the cost of representing the employee. The employee doesn't have to join the union, or even pay full dues; he or she just has to compensate the union for the union's cost in representing the employee."

    That fact is often lost in the flood of false claims made by proponents of RTW. An op-ed piece penned by state Rep. Mike Shirkey (R-Clark Lake) is a perfect example.

    "Michigan is about to liberate hard working Michigan citizens from the
    unnatural burden of forced union membership."

    The truth of the matter is, no such liberation is necessary. As Dau-Schmidt noted, "Under federal law, unions are required to represent all of the employees in their bargaining unit, whether the employee is a union member or not."

    "Federal law," he added, "also ensures that no one can be required to join a union." (The emphasis is his.)

    What RTW laws really do is relieve employees of the obligation to compensate unions for bargaining on their behalf, and for representing their interests if there is a cause for filing a grievance.

    That is why critics of RTW sometimes derisively refer to it as the "right to be a freeloader" law.

    1 2 3 Next Page

    > Email Curt Guyette

    We welcome user discussion on our site, under the following guidelines:

    To comment you must first create a profile and sign-in with a verified DISQUS account or social network ID. Sign up here.

    Comments in violation of the rules will be denied, and repeat violators will be banned. Please help police the community by flagging offensive comments for our moderators to review. By posting a comment, you agree to our full terms and conditions. Click here to read terms and conditions.
    comments powered by Disqus


    Metro Times

    733 St Antoine

    Detroit, MI 48226

    Main: (313) 961-4060

    Advertising: (313) 961-4060

    Classified: (313) 962-5277

    Contact MT | Advertise | National Advertising | Work Here

    All parts of this site Copyright © 2013 Detroit Metro Times.

    News

    News+Views

    Politics & Prejudices

    News Hits

    Stir It Up

    Higher Ground

    Comics

    Blogs

    Music Blahg

    News Blawg

    Reckless Eyeballing

    The B-Roll

    Blowout Blog

    Best of Detroit

    Best of Detroit

    Best of Detroit 2010

    Best of Map

    Music

    Music Homepage

    Album Reviews

    Add Music Event

    Search Music Events

    Arts

    Arts Homepage

    Book Reviews

    Culture

    Culture Homepage

    Savage Love

    Motor City Cribs & Rides

    Screens

    Screens Homepage

    Film Reviews

    Idiot Boxing

    Events

    Calendar

    Search Calendar Events

    Enter Calendar Event

    Art

    Benefit

    Civics

    Comedy

    Dance

    Family

    Film

    Talks Plus

    LGBT

    Literary

    Music

    Special events

    Sports

    Theater

    Food

    Food Homepage

    Find a Restaurant

    Clubs

    Find a Club

    Classified

    Classified Home

    Place Ad

    Jobs

    Services

    Stuff For Sale

    Massage

    Personals

    Adult

    Automotive

    Cars, Trucks+More

    Services

    Real Estate

    Real Estate

    For Rent

    Roommates

    Archives

    Search Archives

    Search Authors

    Search Issues

    Latest Comments

    Get Our Newsletters

    Enter your email address to get our weekly emails.

     

    Metro Times Stuff

    Win Free Stuff

    Velvet Rope Photos

    Event Photos

    Social Media

    Facebook

    MySpace

    Flickr

    Twitter

    Youtube

    RSS Feed

     Full Feed