• About MT
  • Advertise
  • Contact
  • STORE
  • RSS Feeds

Get our issue, highlights, free stuff and more!

  • Blogs
  • News
  • Arts+Culture
  • Music
  • Screens
  • Food
  • Calendar
  • Best of Detroit
  • Classifieds
  • Slideshows
  • Free Stuff
  • Careers
  • Dating
  • Clubs
  • Archives
  • MMJ
  • Blowout
  • Adult Classifieds
  • Calendar

    Detroit Daily Deals powered by ReferLocal
    • New Comments
    • Popular Threads
    • Most Read
    Most Read
    • Politucs & Prejudices Is the system hopeless? | 5/22/2013
    • They Don’t Care What You Think They don’t care what you want | 5/15/2013
    • Steam Dreaming Fans are getting hot and bothered for a new steampunk confab. | 5/22/2013
    • Penrose Rising Changes are under way. | 5/15/2013
    • Savage Love Closure and watersports. | 5/22/2013
    • Gracie See Pizzeria West side institution | 5/22/2013
    • The Epic Career of Screenwriter Dan Shere From viral videos to feature length films. | 5/22/2013

    Print Email

    News Hits

    Font affront

    Why the type size issue isn't the real point of the battle over the state’s emergency manager law.

    Photo: , License: N/A

    Ryan Schirmang of the Signal-Return printing center measures 14-point type the old way.

    Photo: , License: N/A

    The Michigan Supreme Court takes measure of point sizes and democracy in the age of computer printing.


    By Curt Guyette

    Published: August 1, 2012

    "It strikes me that there is a lot of uncertainty here," said Young.

    If the current dispute had occurred back in the 1950s, when the law was written, it could have been settled definitively by having the printer bring in the block used, and it could be measured. 

    But now that fonts are computer-generated, and printer's blocks have gone the way of buggy whips, what's the court supposed to do?

    That's the dilemma the chief justice says the court is dealing with.

    But it's really a false dilemma.

    Attorneys for Stand Up for Democracy — a team that includes lawyers representing the left-leaning Sugar Law Center and National Lawyers Guild along with the NAACP and organized labor — contend that, based on the computer software used to create the petition, the group has met the 14-point requirement. Beyond that, though, is established precedent that says as long as a proposed ballot measure is in "substantial compliance" with the law, then it should be allowed to go before voters so that they can have their say.

    As Justice Stephen J. Markman pointed out during oral arguments, "We have been living, more or less, in a substantial compliance world since 2001 at least."

    Why, he asked, is it fair to change the rules now?

    Good question.

    Which brings us to the true heart of this matter.

    Stand Up for Democracy lead attorney Herbert Sanders, in summing up his side's position in all this, told the court that this isn't really about the law. Instead, he said, it's a matter of philosophy.

    Do we want this to be a state where people clearly have the ability to overturn laws passed by the Legislature, or do we want this to be a place where access to the ballot is filled with hurdles, and a dispute over something that amounts to no more than the thickness of a single dime can be used to stifle democracy?

    In response to that, Citizens for Fiscal Responsibility attorney John Pirich argued that the case isn't about philosophy at all, but rather "is about the law, plain and simple."

    "You suffer the consequences if you don't comply with the law," he told the court.

    Interestingly, as Justice Michael F. Cavanagh points out, Pirich was arguing out of the other side of his mouth a decade ago. Cavanagh read into the record Pirich's passionate and articulate argument that nitpicky technical deficiencies shouldn't be used to deny people the right to vote.

    How did Pirich explain the 180-degree turn away from that position? With the attorney seeming to be momentarily stunned by the question, Chief Justice Young leapt in (oddly, it seemed to us) providing an answer: 

    "Different day, different client," he offered helpfully, as some in the courtroom chuckled.

    But this isn't a joke.

    Fundamental principles of democracy are at stake here.

    It doesn't get any more serious than that.

     

     

    News Hits is written by Curt Guyette. Contact the column at 313-202-8004.

    Previous Page 1 2

    > Email Curt Guyette

    We welcome user discussion on our site, under the following guidelines:

    To comment you must first create a profile and sign-in with a verified DISQUS account or social network ID. Sign up here.

    Comments in violation of the rules will be denied, and repeat violators will be banned. Please help police the community by flagging offensive comments for our moderators to review. By posting a comment, you agree to our full terms and conditions. Click here to read terms and conditions.
    comments powered by Disqus


    Metro Times

    733 St Antoine

    Detroit, MI 48226

    Main: (313) 961-4060

    Advertising: (313) 961-4060

    Classified: (313) 962-5277

    Contact MT | Advertise | National Advertising | Work Here

    All parts of this site Copyright © 2013 Detroit Metro Times.

    News

    News+Views

    Politics & Prejudices

    News Hits

    Stir It Up

    Higher Ground

    Comics

    Blogs

    Music Blahg

    News Blawg

    Reckless Eyeballing

    The B-Roll

    Blowout Blog

    Best of Detroit

    Best of Detroit

    Best of Detroit 2010

    Best of Map

    Music

    Music Homepage

    Album Reviews

    Add Music Event

    Search Music Events

    Arts

    Arts Homepage

    Book Reviews

    Culture

    Culture Homepage

    Savage Love

    Motor City Cribs & Rides

    Screens

    Screens Homepage

    Film Reviews

    Idiot Boxing

    Events

    Calendar

    Search Calendar Events

    Enter Calendar Event

    Art

    Benefit

    Civics

    Comedy

    Dance

    Family

    Film

    Talks Plus

    LGBT

    Literary

    Music

    Special events

    Sports

    Theater

    Food

    Food Homepage

    Find a Restaurant

    Clubs

    Find a Club

    Classified

    Classified Home

    Place Ad

    Jobs

    Services

    Stuff For Sale

    Massage

    Personals

    Adult

    Automotive

    Cars, Trucks+More

    Services

    Real Estate

    Real Estate

    For Rent

    Roommates

    Archives

    Search Archives

    Search Authors

    Search Issues

    Latest Comments

    Get Our Newsletters

    Enter your email address to get our weekly emails.

     

    Metro Times Stuff

    Win Free Stuff

    Velvet Rope Photos

    Event Photos

    Social Media

    Facebook

    MySpace

    Flickr

    Twitter

    Youtube

    RSS Feed

     Full Feed