It seems you're using an old browser. In order to view this site correctly, we advise you to upgrade your browser, or try the free Mozilla Firefox.
Bookmark and Share   Email this Story Print-ready version leave a comment
[8]

Visual arts

Right place, weird time
Showing us our city, through their eyes
"Renee," "Jamal" and "Zana," photographs from Dutch transplant Corine Vermeulen-Smith
SEE ALSO
More Visual arts Stories

Hush (12/9/2009)
PostSecret's Frank Warren on online anonymity, Oprah and when a secret is no longer a secret

Duped (11/11/2009)
Hamtramck slips Xerox some acid

He comes in colors (10/21/2009)
Hubert Massey enriches neighborhoods, one story and one mural at a time

More from Rebecca Mazzei

Pakistan beyond headlines (10/1/2008)
A humanities teacher shifts the focus

Pakistan beyond the headlines (10/1/2008)
A humanities teacher shifts the focus

Wake up the neighborhood (9/17/2008)
Detroit resources include land and artists. Here's how to use both. Plus: WDET author interview.

 

A place can have definite or indefinite boundaries. Places, in my mind, have always been marked by very definite barriers. It's a product of growing up with a younger brother who is handicapped. Some time, very early on, I unconsciously made the decision to join him on his journey, and began processing my experiences in terms of the physicality of my surroundings. It's like second nature now: Is this terrain flat or bumpy? Is it wet? How many people are sharing it? How soon will I be moving from this location to a new one? As an adult, I am more often than not somewhere he can't easily be — say, hiking in a forest or walking up three flights of stairs in an old apartment building — and my barrier has become emotional. It's guilt. 

A heightened sense of awareness characterizes a really wonderful, intimate exhibit entitled Walking Distance, on display at Hamtramck's 2739 Edwin gallery through the end of the month. In photos, drawings, paintings, video and installation, 10 artists do more than document urban landscapes; they explore what defines our relationship with the world around us. The topic seems to be on the minds of many artists, as humanity continues to lose touch with the real world. 

Walking Distance guides us around an array of local spots that are at once common and barely recognizable. Emily Linn, whose family has lived in Detroit for seven generations, researched 13 routine routes in Detroit that members of her family once traveled. She walked these paths with a camera at her side, shooting the street beneath her feet. The concrete flows fast down the screen like a stream, and bounces to the rhythm of her gait. The footage affords frustratingly little opportunity for the viewer to develop any real connection to a place that means so much to her. In a subtle language, she manages to honor her ancestry while expressing the loss she's struggling with; the futility of seeking to reclaim everyday moments that have long passed. 

Guests entering the gallery at 2739 are greeted by a zoetrope made from wooden figures on a turntable. Artist and animator Gary Schwartz was diagnosed with multiple sclerosis in the mid- '70s. Since then, he has occasionally lost the ability to walk, and writes in his artist statement that he has been fixated on the "walking cycle" as it manifests itself in motion picture, kinetic sculpture, stop-motion animation and more. His piece seems as heartbreakingly cruel as it does playful, because the freedom of mobility is a delusion set in motion by a strobe light. The power of the zoetrope is a result of our eyes deceiving us, just as illness betrays the body. 

The strength of this show is, in part, credited to its curator, Steve Panton, who displayed the work so that visual cues guide eyes from one piece to the next. Gateways into new worlds form fences, doors and windows in Toby Millman's photographs, a Brooklyn transplant just getting to know her new neighborhood, while Laura Macintyre's paintings celebrate the vibrancy of an area she's lived in her whole life. The setting, for both of them, is Hamtramck. 

Imposing concrete barricades in Scott Hocking's photos — inched apart just enough for someone on foot to pass through — represent a gateway that takes us from one era to the next. For 10 years, Hocking has tracked the evolution of what is known as the "I-94 Industrial Park Renaissance Zone," an area of about 289 acres located close to Hamtramck on the city's east side, between St. Cyril and Mount Elliot. The neighborhood was once residential, but gradual depopulation led to the demolition of homes. Hocking explains that the area was used as a dumping ground and eventually the barricades were put in place. The expansive territory in his photos now occupies an incredible interplace between civilization and total collapse. It's a section of Detroit that has returned to the condition of fertile landscape Count Pontchartrain described in 1709 as "the earthly paradise of North America," replete with wildlife and natural landscape. The Detroit Economic Growth Corporation, reads the State of Michigan's website, seeks businesses for "industrial redevelopment." Invested with such social power, Hocking's lush landscapes are also an indictment of a city and state government floundering with little vision.

The subject matter in Walking Distance may be local, but it's far from provincial. As a side note, while art of the local landscape hangs on the wall, the creators have been in and out of the country, working and vacationing in China, Panama, Germany, Italy, Los Angeles and Philadelphia. 

Corine Vermeulen-Smith is relatively new to the local art community; she's from the Netherlands, and her photos of local residents look like stunningly contemporary interpretations of 17th century Dutch paintings. The placement of a hand on the knee, the cropping of a woman in an oversized jacket and the slight tilt of head gives off the air of classic nobility and beauty. For four days, Vermeulen-Smith, with Femke Lutgerink (who provided text), turned a formerly foreclosed home on Klinger Street in Hamtramck into a "Walk-In Portrait Studio," where she shot pictures of strangers for free. Vermeulen-Smith opened up shop as a way of introducing herself to the community where she and her husband recently bought a home. "It was like baking an apple pie and saying, 'Hi, I'm your new neighbor,'" she writes in an e-mail. She adds that she'd like to continue this project as a traveling photo studio, documenting different communities around Detroit. 

Painter Kathy Rashid turns her attention to cracks in the sidewalk, focusing on a spot about as big as where nearly one foot can rest. In her interpretation, a place is an intimate story told millions of times. 

The show's most abstract piece is Chris Samuel's installation, a waist-high construction of a gate, some paint cans and mirrors reflecting the steps of those who pass in front of it. This is a poignant representation of an environment built up from imbalance, yet surprisingly functional as it now stands.

Rebecca Mazzei is a Metro Times contributing editor. Send comments to letters@metrotimes.com.

Comments

Report this comment On 6/17/2009 9:37:12 AM, Fortuna said:

What a treat to find a review written by Rebecca Mazzei in this weeks MT. More of the same, please.

Report this comment On 6/19/2009 10:22:44 AM, bmajestic said:

Really?? "contemporary interpretations of 17th century Dutch paintings." Just because she is from the Netherlands? What if Vermeulen-Smith happened to be from Germany or Ireland or Spain? Would these same photographs be "contemporary interpretations" of earlier century paintings of those countries?

Report this comment On 6/19/2009 2:42:16 PM, rmazzei said:

Um, really, yes. Corine's work reminds me of Dutch portraiture from that era because of the formality in the composition, rather than reminding me of, say, Caravaggio's portraiture, which is full of expressiveness.

Report this comment On 6/19/2009 3:50:35 PM, bmajestic said:

I guess my point is - Is it too easy /obvious for you to be reminded of Dutch paintings because Corine is Dutch? And why paintings? Why not other photographers? Why not the "formal portraiture" of say Karsh, Irving Penn, etc. And also why do photographs still have to be compared to paintings in order to assume some legitimacy with the "Art" world. You talked to her - is her conscious approach actually influenced or modeled after the Dutch Masters?

Report this comment On 6/19/2009 10:30:35 PM, rmazzei said:

I'm not sure I'm necessarily saying her work reminds me of Dutch portraiture because she is Dutch -- that's what you're assuming I mean. (Although I have to say that a country's tradition, especially such a potent one, does have a deep impact on who you are as an artist, and I'd debate with anyone who thinks there is no such thing as art that looks "American.") I don't know if Corine consciously attempts an approach modeled after Dutch masters, but that kind of psychogeographical influence is such an ingrained part of who we are as people, it can be difficult to even realize it when it surfaces. Also, does it make a difference whether she meant it? I think reception-oriented criticism is just as valid as that which is centered on intention. Lastly, your point is a good one about photography too often being compared to painting. But just looking at "Zana," I don't know what to tell you. I don't see Irving Penn, I see Vermeer.

Report this comment On 6/22/2009 12:38:59 AM, bmajestic said:

What I'm saying is exactly that; The artist is Dutch so it's not much of a stretch for you to compare her work to the Dutch art tradition. It then becomes a nice neat package. Seems reasonable and logical and predictable. As I proffered a couple of posts ago and maybe wasn't clear in my hypothetical - if Corine happened to be German,would you still say that her portraits (these same portraits) reminded you of Vermeer and other Dutch portraiture or would you be compelled to find something in her work akin to the German portraiture tradition because she is German? My guess is that you would. After all, what would be the point of comparing a German photographer's American made portraits to the Dutch Masters. Or the Dutch photographer's American made portraits to another Dutch photographer's portraits which are reminiscent of the Dutch Masters. Back where we started. Right! I'm assuming you mean that her work reminds you of Dutch portraiture because she is Dutch because that is actually what you said in the article. You made a point of saying she is from the Netherlands and "her photos of local residents look like stunningly contemporary interpretations of 17th century Dutch paintings." Why?? BECAUSE SHE IS DUTCH AND SHE IS FROM THE NETHERLANDS. Sorry about that. On the one hand I agree with you. It should not be a surprise that her portraits would seem to look like 17th century portraits because once one knows Corine is Dutch, then there is an automatic compulsion to see something in her work to connect to that tradition. Again, a nice neat package. Yeah, the "formality" of it all and the "classic nobility and beauty" does not belong exclusively to Dutch painters. I don't see the main characteristic of the Dutch painters in Corine's work shown (3) in the article. Namely the lighting. The beautiful side window light referred to as "Rembrant lighting". Well, we see what we want to see to make our case. I realize I'm been a nit-picker here and I know you're trying to help with your reviews. But wouldn't it help to cite other photographers past and present who've documented their communities in much the same way Corine intends to do? Mike Disfarmer http://www.disfarmer.com/ who photographed the people of a small town in Arkansas 1939-1945 is a good example and a more relevent tradition to be compared to. Thanks.

Report this comment On 6/22/2009 8:52:42 AM, rmazzei said:

You know what? The only thing hugely compelling to me about Corine's photos are their compositional structure. The concept is pretty par for the course in Detroit, and has been done elsewhere too. So if you want to call the guy in Arkansas, or bring up Walker Evans, or talk to her about her social practice, you can. It's not what interests me in her work.

Report this comment On 6/22/2009 8:54:54 AM, rmazzei said:

I realize it's probably what she would prefer I discuss, as well. And if you, or her, want to discuss community relations and how that should be composed, we can and should. Thanks Bmajestic, for the input.

COMMENT ON THIS ARTICLE

Leave a comment on this article.

User:
Password:

By posting a message, you agree to our Posting Policies No account? New users sign up here.
Forgot your password?

  • Events
  • Eats
  • Drinks

Keyword search

Detailed search

Preferences

Critic's picks

Non-recurring

All ages

Keyword search

Browse restaurants

Search by:

Cuisines (1769)

City (1768)

Neighborhood (82)

Reviewed (476)

Critic's pick (165)

Open 24 hours (25)

Late dinner (390)

Brunch (152)

Takeout (649)

Delivery (140)

Outdoor dining (227)

Kid friendly (411)

Serving

Food (1175)

Microbrew (231)

No alcohol (91)

Featuring

Dance floor (844)

Darts (628)

Billiards (700)

Games (764)

TV (1081)

Outdoor seating (404)

Wheelchair access (852)

Keyword search

Detailed Search

> PLACE CLASSIFIED AD

Untitled Document
APPLY TODAY: Start Tomorrow
LAW ENFORCEMENT: Full time, Part time
TRUCK DRIVER: Full time, Part time
View all TOP JOBS ads
ROOMS FOR RENT: Homes & Apartments Available
View all TOP HOMES/RENTALS ads
BANKRUPTCY: Criminal Defense, Family Law, Firearms
RASOR LAW FIRM PLLC.: Sharp. Agressive. Responsive.
View all TOP ATTORNEY ads